Map Lovers’ Monday: Circles of Destruction

I am just a few years too young to have gone through the “duck-and-cover” drills that so many schoolchildren had to endure during the 1950s and 1960s, when a nuclear conflict with the Soviet Union was deemed a plausible possibility. The maps below are a remnant of that fearful time, and whether you believe that the threat was real or something ginned up by the government to get us to accept the massive military buildup that accompanied the Cold War, they are still chilling documents.

These maps are now in the collection of the City Archives of Philadelphia, but I found them in a collection of Civil Defense material at the City Plans Unit of the Streets Department, while searching for maps showing evidence of man-made changes in the city’s landscape. Fortunately, the drastic changes that the Civil Defense maps suggest have never come to pass.

Many of the maps – like the two below, showing transportation routes and the city’s drinking water facilities – seem innocuous at first glance, until you notice the concentric circles overdrawn on them.

Street map of Philadelphia and vicinity showing street car, bus and subway-elevated lines. Philadelphia Transportation Company. April 1948. Overdrawn ca. 1950 with two sets of concentric circles labeled A, B, C, and D. (City Archives of Philadelphia)
Contour map of Philadelphia Area. Existing Districts. Trunk main piping, sizes 10″ & over. Department of Public Works, Bureau of Water, Drawing no. 29-A-792, August 16, 1941. Overdrawn ca. 1950 with concentric circles labeled A, B, C, and D. Handwritten notes: “Confidential. Furnished to N.S.R.B. [National Security Resources Board] for use in civil defense problems.”

So, what are these circles? They are blast zones radiating out from Ground Zero, the center of an atomic bomb strike. The map below explains this, and quantifies the potential loss of life.

Distribution of Total Population 1940. Philadelphia City Planning Commission, October 1945. Overdrawn ca. 1950 with two sets of concentric circles, representing atomic bomb blasts, and text detailing potential casualties from these “bursts.” (City Archives of Philadelphia)

In the file drawer with these maps I also found a shaded disk of plastic, which was probably pinned over the circles on various plans during public meetings, to make the blast zones easily apparent from a distance. The central A zone, labeled “Area of Total Destruction,” is blood-red, with the colors fading to pink as the expected damage lessens. Below is a map with and without the disks overlaid.

Philadelphia and vicinity. Philadelphia City Planning Commission, 1945. Overdrawn ca. 1950 with two sets of concentric circles labeled A, B, C, and D, indicating levels of damage from a possible atomic bomb blast. Colored circles added digitally from scan of plastic disks accompanying the map. (City Archives of Philadelphia)

The map below shows the colored circles drawn onto a regional road map. Why there are not more circles in this wider area may have been a failure of imagination on the part of local Civil Defense officials, but I’d rather think it was an act of hopefulness. Two strikes would have been awful enough; more might have been too dreadful to contemplate.

Philadelphia and vicinity transportation map. Highways, railroads, canals, air lanes, and dredged channels. Federal Works Agency, Public roads Administration. Revised edition 1943. Overdrawn ca. 1950 with two sets of concentric circles, in bright magenta shades, indicating the damage from a possible atomic bomb blast.

As YouTube user @maxkronader5225 wrote in the comments to the Duck and Cover video linked at the top of the page: “I am old enough to have done duck and cover drills. I once thought them preposterous, given the power of nuclear weapons. But then I realized duck and cover drills were never meant to save people a mile from ground zero; they were intended to save people 20 miles+ from ground zero.”

Philadelphia Civil Defense Council, Mayor Bernard Samuel, Coordinator, Information Bulletin No. 1 If air raids should come… 1950 ca. (Collection of Adam Levine). I altered the background color of the original brochure from a mild butter yellow into a dangerous-looking acid yellow that I thought more appropriate to the subject matter.

FEEDBACK